Threads doesn’t just reward replies — it was built for them.
Adam Mosseri has made this clear more than one time, and has not minced his words. “The sum of all your replies is about as valuable as the sum of all the value of all your posts,” he said Platformer.
He wasn’t lying. Data shows how effective Threads responses can be.
Replying to comments on your Threads posts can boost engagement by around 42% — the highest lift we’ve seen across any platform — according to Buffer data scientist Julian Winternheimer’s analysis There are over 128,000 threads.
Julian’s research shows that Threads performs significantly better than its own baseline when users engage with other Threads. Platform’s design rewards conversations in ways other platforms don’t. social networks don’t.
The analysis included other platforms, but the impact on Threads from comments was much greater. LinkedIn was ranked second, but (can we say that only? The 30% growth was a surprise.
Learn what makes Threads unique, what Julian found out, and how this affects how you appear on the platform.
✨
Analysis
Julian was faced with a tough reality when he tried to understand if replying comments on Threads actually moved the needle. Larger accounts are more likely to be engaged than smaller ones. It wouldn’t be very useful to compare them.
Instead of asking “Do accounts that reply perform better,” He said: “Does the same account perform better on posts where it replies versus posts where it doesn’t?”
This approach — using what’s called a fixed-effects regression model — lets us isolate the impact of replying by comparing each account to itself. The comparison already includes all the variables which make each account unique, such as follower count, niche and posting frequency.
Julian ran Z-score analysis as a check. This measures how each post performed relative to that account’s typical engagement — basically, did this post overperform or underperform compared to what’s normal for that brand or creator?
The results were the same for both methods. When you have such consistency it is hard to believe that the results are random.
There are a few points to note upfront.
- The correlation is not necessarily causation. You may get more replies from creators when posts naturally gain popularity. This is because more people are responding to them.
- This pattern was found on all six platforms that Julian studied (Threads). LinkedIn, Instagram. X, Bluesky, Facebook) and saw lifts ranging anywhere from 5%-42%. Threads came out on top by a wide margin.
- The Julian’s Threads data set includes over 128,000 postings, giving us a solid statistical basis.
Creators’ posts that respond to the comments made by viewers 42% higher engagement on average — even after controlling for whether the post received any comments at all.
Julian’s analysis found that engagement wasn’t just slightly higher for posts with replies — it was dramatically higher. Around Two-thirds profiles They responded to the comments with positive results.
This was confirmed by the Z-score. Posts that received replies from the creator consistently scored higher than an account’s average engagement level.
This is especially striking because of the difference between Threads and all other platforms. Comparing the two platforms is important.
| The Platform | Engagement lift (vs. baseline) |
|---|---|
| Threads | +42% |
| The following are some of the most recent LinkedIn posts: | +30% |
| +21% | |
| +9% | |
| Twitter/X | +8% |
| Bluesky | +5% |
The Threads platform rewards responses more than other platforms
At its launch in 2023, critics dismissed Threads immediately as a Twitter clone. In three years, it has grown to over 400 millions monthly active users. Meta’s promise that Threads prioritizes conversation over broadcasting has been proven true.
Platform wants to connect people, and not have them shouting into the air.
It’s very obvious that the architecture of the platform gives replies equal weight. A thoughtful response is displayed on the same page as the original posting.
“Elevating the reply to the same level as the original post allows for much more robust, diverse discourse,” Mosseri explained this in an interview. The Verge. “Which is part of the reason we didn’t just try to shove this thing into the feed on Instagram or a separate tab.”
This results in a platform that rewards conversation algorithmically.
You can reply to comments in Threads.
If you want to extend the life of the thread: The total number of engagement signals is calculated by adding each reply to the original post. Threads’ algorithm This conversation deserves to be shown to more people. The feeds of a post that is generating active conversation will stay longer in your feed than if it was just a couple likes.
When you signal that your relationship is strong, Threads keeps track of who is interacting with whom. When you consistently engage with someone’s comments, the platform learns that connection matters — and is more likely to show your future posts to them (and theirs to you).
The behavior that you desire to see is what you should model: They’re likely to participate if you show that you are actively participating. Engagement creates a positive cycle, where more engagement is generated.
Mosseri’s advice “reply much more than you post” In theory, it sounds fantastic. In practice, it can feel a little overwhelming — especially if you’re used to platforms where posting is the primary activity and engagement is secondary.
What if you thought about Threads in a different way?
Do not think of posts as finished items: You can chat with anyone who posts. Imagine them as conversation starters. It’s the responses that do the most work, and provide the greatest opportunity.
You don’t have to write long replies: Then, “Exactly!” You can also find out more about “I hadn’t thought about it that way” It is sufficient to maintain a conversation. It is more important to be a part of the conversation than dominate it.
Join the conversation beyond your own post: Mosseri emphasized that it is important to reply to the posts of others, and not just make comments about your own. By adding thoughtful comments to the posts of people within your niche, or in your community, you increase your visibility and develop relationships.
View the ratio You’re not using Threads to its full potential if you post 5 times a week but respond only to a few comments. You could try flipping it: post only 2-3 times a day and engage with other users the rest of the time.
It feels very different to how we were all taught. use social media. However, Threads doesn’t represent the majority of social media platforms.
This 42% increase in engagement is impressive. You can only reply consistently if you are able to maintain the habit.
What has worked (and not) for you?
Use Threads as a group chat (really large): The time I spend on Threads is shorter than the amount of time I use LinkedIn or Instagram. Five minutes now, ten there. I’m not scheduling posts and walking away — I’m popping in, seeing what’s happening, adding to conversations.
First reply, then post: After I have opened Threads, the first thing I do is check for notifications. Then I reply to all comments that were made about my posts. Then I’ll consider posting something. I don’t want to fall into the trap where you just post content and never engage.
Do not let perfection be your enemy: On some days, I respond with thoughtful paragraphs. Sometimes I write a lighter reply, a GIF with a simple thought (peak-millennial!). Each contributes to the conversation. Threads is notified that both of us are present.
Use Buffer’s Community feature Stay organized As someone who manages multiple platforms, being able to have all of my comments together in one location has made life much easier. It’s easy to see what Threads have comments that are unanswered without having to open the app or scroll through it. The app is free and works on up to three platforms. It also includes a comment score that measures your consistency in replying over time.

Expectations should be realistic It’s not necessary to respond to each and every comment in order to get results. Julian’s research found that two thirds of the accounts saw positive results, indicating even modest engagement can make a difference.
It is not about perfection, but consistency that counts.
Threads is a replying system.
Julian’s study analyzed 2,000,000 posts and Threads was the only platform to achieve a 42% increase in engagement.
Threads is built to reply: the architecture, the algorithms, the culture… Everything points towards conversation as the primary activity, not an afterthought.
You’ve got to be trying. grow on ThreadsIt’s pretty simple math: invest more time in engaging and less time broadcasting. Respond to comments made on your post. Respond to comments on your posts. Conversations should continue.
This boost of 42% is not guaranteed to every user or post, but you will have a better chance if Threads becomes the platform for conversation it was intended to be.
✨

