Biden’s administration, war or no, was making a big bet: that America could leverage its influence to slow down China, that any losses incurred in the form of lost US exports and damage to bilateral relations would still be worthwhile. One hand, the gamble was made on Washington’s ideas from decades before. Since the Cold War, US policymakers have used tech restrictions to slow down China’s modernization of its military and punish it for abuses against human rights. Recent advances in surveillance and missile technology have reinforced this logic. Several people from the Biden Administration say the bet was motivated by a novel concern.
Key officials believed AI was approaching an inflection point—or several—that could give a nation major military and economic advantages. Others believed that a self improving system, or artificial general intelligence (AGI), was just around the corner. China’s potential to reach these levels first is too high to ignore.
The Biden Administration’s response is described based on an interview with over 10 former US policy and government officials, including some who spoke under the condition of anonymity in order to speak about internal deliberations.
Hobbling Huawei
Biden’s administration didn’t start at zero when introducing its transformative policies. In his first term as president, Donald Trump also focused on Chinese technology, including semiconductor companies, in an effort to limit the rise of China’s global technological influence.
Commerce Department to Launch New Initiatives in 2019 added Huawei, the Chinese IT company, was added to this Entity List. It effectively isolated Huawei from US suppliers, and thus its chips supply, until it obtained a license. They justified it by alleging that Huawei was in violation of US sanctions towards Iran. They also believed the measure was intended to harm the company as a whole, because they thought that Huawei could be used by Chinese spy agencies and saboteurs.
Next, Trump’s administration escalated the attack by using an obscure legal provision called “foreign-produced direct product rule.” The FDPR was originally designed to make sure that goods made through US innovation and technology—like missiles or airplane parts—didn’t go into weapons systems sold to adversaries, even if those systems were built abroad. This long-arm weapon was used by the Trump Administration to specifically target Huawei’s products in 2020. “efforts to obtain advanced semiconductors developed or produced from US software and technology,” Wilbur R. Ross is the Commerce Secretary said At the time.
The FDPR has been previously used to enforce multilateral arm controls. “items made with US technology that were not sensitive, that were not on the control list, that had nothing to do with any AI,” Kevin Wolf says, an ex-official in the Obama administration responsible for export controls.
“Everybody thought that would be the end of this very novel extraterritorial control,” Wolf said. In fact, it was the US Government that found the FDPR unresistable. The US would turn the FDPR against Russia in 2022 after its invasion of Ukraine and use it as a weapon to restrict high-powered computing systems in China. “Obviously we started using it like candy,” says Estevez. “Certainly threatening to use it, if not actually using it.”

